top of page

Wrist Heart Rate Monitor vs Chest Heart Rate Monitor: Which Is Best for Your Workouts?

Writer's picture: Harry SmithHarry Smith

Heart rate monitors have become an essential tool for fitness enthusiasts, athletes, and anyone looking to track their health and performance. They provide invaluable insights into how your body responds to exercise, helping you train smarter, not just harder.


But the big question is: Should you choose a wrist heart rate monitor or a chest strap heart rate monitor?


Both options have their advantages and drawbacks, and the right choice depends on your goals, activity type, and preferences. In this blog, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each, provide examples of popular models, and help you decide which is best for your fitness journey.



What Is a Heart Rate Monitor, and Why Do You Need One?


A heart rate monitor measures your heart rate in beats per minute (BPM) during exercise or rest. It provides real-time data that allows you to:

• Optimize training zones (e.g., fat-burning, cardio, or peak performance)

• Track recovery after intense workouts

• Monitor overall cardiovascular health

• Improve endurance and performance through targeted training


Whether you’re doing CrossFit, running marathons, or simply staying active, heart rate monitors ensure you’re training at the right intensity.


Wrist Heart Rate Monitors: Overview


How They Work

Wrist heart rate monitors, often integrated into smartwatches or fitness trackers, use optical sensors to measure blood flow through your wrist. These sensors emit light onto your skin and detect changes in blood volume, allowing the device to calculate your heart rate.


Benefits of Wrist Heart Rate Monitors

1. Convenience and Comfort: They’re lightweight, easy to wear, and require no additional straps or equipment.

2. 24/7 Monitoring: Wrist monitors can track your heart rate continuously throughout the day and night, making them great for tracking overall health.

3. Multifunctionality: Many wrist monitors also include GPS, sleep tracking, step counting, and more.

4. Ideal for Beginners: They’re user-friendly and don’t require any setup beyond wearing them.


Limitations

1. Accuracy During High-Intensity Workouts: Wrist monitors can struggle to keep up with rapid changes in heart rate during activities like sprinting, HIIT, or CrossFit.

2. Positioning Matters: If the monitor isn’t snug against your skin or is worn incorrectly, readings can be inaccurate.

3. Delayed Response: They may not capture sudden spikes or drops in heart rate as quickly as a chest strap.


Best Wrist Heart Rate Monitors to Buy

1. Garmin Forerunner 255

• Why It’s Great: Perfect for runners and athletes, the Forerunner 255 includes advanced heart rate tracking, VO2 max, and GPS functionality.

• Price: $309 or £299



2. Apple Watch Series 10

• Why It’s Great: Offers excellent 24/7 heart rate tracking, workout metrics, and integration with fitness apps. It’s also a stylish choice for everyday wear.

• Price: $385 or £399




3. Fitbit Charge 5

• Why It’s Great: A budget-friendly option that includes heart rate monitoring, sleep tracking, and stress management features.

• Price: $130 or £139.99





4. Whoop Strap 4.0

• Why It’s Great: The Whoop Strap 4.0 is designed for serious athletes and data enthusiasts. It focuses on recovery, strain, and sleep tracking, providing unparalleled insights into how your body is performing and recovering. The strap is lightweight, screen-free, and integrates seamlessly with the Whoop app for advanced analytics. It’s perfect for those who want a long-term view of their fitness and recovery trends.

• Price: Free with a subscription starting at $30 or £25 per month or $230 for a full year.


Chest Strap Heart Rate Monitors: Overview


How They Work

Chest strap heart rate monitors use electrical sensors to detect your heart’s electrical activity. The strap is worn snugly around your chest and transmits data to a connected device, such as your phone, watch, or fitness app.


Benefits of Chest Strap Heart Rate Monitors

1. Superior Accuracy: They provide more reliable and precise heart rate data, especially during high-intensity workouts.

2. Responsive to Changes: Chest straps capture rapid fluctuations in heart rate, making them ideal for activities like CrossFit, interval training, and cycling.

3. Works Across Devices: Many models connect seamlessly with fitness apps, smartwatches, and treadmills.


Limitations

1. Less Comfortable: Wearing a strap around your chest can feel restrictive or uncomfortable for some users.

2. No 24/7 Monitoring: Chest straps are typically worn during exercise only, so they don’t track resting heart rate or daily activity.

3. Setup Required: You need to pair the device with an app or watch before use.


Best Chest Strap Heart Rate Monitors to Buy

1. Polar H10

• Why It’s Great: Known for its exceptional accuracy and compatibility with various apps, the H10 is a favourite among athletes.

• Price: $82 or £89.50





2. Wahoo TRACKR

• Why It’s Great: Tracks heart rate, calorie burn, and even running dynamics. It’s lightweight and works with most devices.

• Price: $84 or £64.99


3. Garmin HRM-Pro

• Why It’s Great: Offers advanced metrics like running dynamics and stores workout data for later syncing. Perfect for triathletes.

• Price: $120 or £119.99





Comparing Wrist and Chest Heart Rate Monitors


Feature

Wrist Monitor

Chest Strap Monitor

Accuracy

Good, but less precise for some exercises

Excellent for all workouts

Comfort

Very Comfortable

Can feel restrictive

Ease of Use

Ready to go, no setup required

Requires pairing with a device

24/7 Monitoring

Yes

No

Cost

Moderate to High

Moderate

Best For

Daily wear, casual exercise

Serious athletes, Longer Workouts


Which One Should You Choose?


Go for a Wrist Heart Rate Monitor If:

• You want an all-in-one device for health, fitness, and lifestyle tracking.

• You do moderate workouts, such as walking, yoga, or steady-state cardio.

• Comfort and convenience are top priorities.


Opt for a Chest Strap Heart Rate Monitor If:

• Accuracy is your top priority, especially for high-intensity or endurance training.

• You’re a serious athlete or someone following specific heart rate zones for training.

• You don’t mind the extra step of wearing and pairing a chest strap.


Real-Life Scenarios: Which Works Best?

1. CrossFit Athlete:

A chest strap like the Polar H10 ensures accuracy during fast-paced WODs (workouts of the day), where heart rates spike and drop frequently.

2. Casual Runner:

A wrist monitor like the Garmin Forerunner 255 is perfect for tracking steady runs and monitoring other fitness metrics.

3. Endurance Cyclist:

The Garmin HRM-Pro chest strap offers precise heart rate tracking and advanced metrics, critical for long rides.

4. General Fitness Enthusiast:

A wrist-based tracker like the Fitbit Charge 5 balances functionality, ease of use, and affordability.


Wrist Heart Rate Monitor vs Chest Heart Rate Monitor


Both wrist and chest heart rate monitors have their place in the fitness world. Your choice depends on your training style, priorities, and budget. For casual use and all-day tracking, a wrist monitor is the way to go. For precision and performance, a chest strap reigns supreme.


If you’re still undecided, consider combining both options. Many fitness enthusiasts use a chest strap for high-intensity sessions and a wrist monitor for day-to-day tracking.


Whatever you choose, investing in a heart rate monitor is a step toward optimizing your performance and staying on top of your health. Now, it’s time to pick your monitor and start smashing those fitness goals!

Comments


AMRAP Antics 8 week Crossfit Program For Athletes
bottom of page